Monday 5 September 2016

ULIP and Mutual Fund Comparison

ULIP and Mutual Fund Comparison


Mutual Funds & ULIPs differ on various key factors like fund switching options, charge structure, liquidity, tax benefits and other major beneficial elements. Here is a detailed comparison between Unit Linked Insurance Plans and Mutual Funds on these aspects.

Unit Linked Insurance Plans And Mutual Funds

Comparison Between Unit Linked Insurance Plans And Mutual Funds

Description
Unit Linked Insurance Plans refer to Unit Linked Insurance Plans offered by insurance companies. These plans allow investors to direct part of their premiums into different types of funds (equity, debt, money market, hybrid etc.).
A mutual fund pools the money from investors and uses it to invest in various securities according to a pre-specified investment objective.
Objective
Unit Linked Insurance Plans are long term plans offering you a dual benefit of insurance and investment.
Mutual funds are ideal investment tool for the short to medium term.
Tax Benefit
All Unit Linked Plans offer tax benefits under section 80C.
Only investments in tax saving funds are eligible for section 80C benefits.
Switching options
Unit Linked Plans (ULIP) allows you to switch your investment between the funds linked to the plan. This enables you to change the risk return.
No switching option is available. If you are not satisfied with the performance of the fund you can exit completely from the same by paying exit charges, if applicable.
Additional Benefits
Some of the Unit Linked Plans give you an additional benefit or loyalty benefit by issuing extra fund units.
There are no additional benefits issued by mutual funds.
Liquidity
Unit Linked Plans have limited liquidity. One needs to stay invested for a minimum period of time as specified in the policy before redeeming the units.
You can easily sell mutual fund units (except for ELSS and funds that have a minimum lock-in period).
Charges structure
Charges in a unit linked plan include mortality charges for the life insurance provided. In addition, premium allocation charge, fund management charge and administration charges are applicable.
Mutual fund charges include an entry load, the annual fund management charge and an exit load, if applicable.
Benefit Snapshot
  • 1. Dual benefit of investment and insurance.
  • 2. Suitable for the long term.
  • 3. Option to switch between the funds is permitted.
  • 4. Offers tax benefits.
  • 1. Investment tool suitable for short to medium term.
  • 2. Easy exit possible.
  • 3. Tax benefit available only on tax saving funds.

Investment Instruments








1. Savings Bank Account
Use only for short-term (less than 30 days) surpluses 

Often the first banking product people use, savings accounts offer low interest (4%-5% p.a.), making them only marginally better than safe deposit lockers. 


2. Money Market Funds (also known as liquid funds)
Offer better returns than savings account without compromising liquidity 

Money market funds are a specialized form of mutual funds that invest in extremely short-term fixed income instruments. Unlike most mutual funds, money market funds are primarily oriented towards protecting your capital and then, aim to maximise returns.

Money market funds usually yield better returns than savings accounts, but lower than bank fixed deposits. With the flexibility to issue cheques from a money market fund account now available, explore this option before putting your money in a savings account. 


3. Bank Fixed Deposit (Bank FDs)
For investors with low risk appetite, best for 6-12 months investment period 

Also referred to as term deposits, this product would be offered by all banks. Minimum investment period for bank FDs is 30 days. 

The ideal investment time for bank FDs is 6 to 12 months as normally interest on bank less than 6 months bank FDs is likely to be lower than money market fund returns. 

It is important to plan your investment time frame while investing in this instrument because early withdrawals typically carry a penalty. 


1. Post Office Savings Schemes (POSS)
Low risk and no TDS 

POSS are popular because they typically yield a higher return than bank FDs. The monthly income plan could suit you if you are a retired individual or have regular income needs. 

Besides the low (Government) risk, the fact that there is no tax deducted at source (TDS) in a POSS is amongst the key attractive features. 

The Post Office offers various schemes that include National Savings Certificates (NSC), National Savings Scheme(NSS), Kisan Vikas Patra, Monthly Income Scheme and Recurring Deposit Scheme. 

Back 
2. Public Provident Fund (PPF)
Best fixed-income investment for high tax payers 

PPF is a very attractive fixed income investment option for small investors primarily because of - 

1. An 11% post-tax return - effective pre-tax rate of 15.7% assuming a 30% tax rate

2. A tax-rebate - deduction of 20% of the amount invested from your tax liability for the year, subject to a maximum Rs60,000 for a tax rebate

3. Low risk - risk attached is Government risk

So, what's the catch? Lack of liquidity is a big negative. You can withdraw your investment made in Year 1 only in Year 7 (although there are some loan options that begin earlier). 

If you are willing to live with poor liquidity, you should invest as much as you can in this scheme before looking for other fixed income investment options. 


3. Company Fixed Deposits (FDs)
Option to maximise returns within a fixed-income portfolio 

FDs are instruments used by companies to borrow from small investors. Typically FDs are open throughout the year. Invest in FDs only if you have surplus funds for more than 12 months. Select your investment period carefully as most FDs are not encashable prior to their maturity. 

Just as in any other instrument, risk is an embedded feature of FDs, more so because it is not mandatory for non-finance companies to get a credit rating for this instrument. 

Investors should consciously (either though a credit rating or through an expert) select the companies they invest in. Quite a few small investors have lost their life's savings by investing in FDs issued by companies that have run into financial problems. 


4. Bonds and Debentures
Option for large investments or to avail of some capital gains tax rebates 

Besides company FDs, bonds and debentures are the other fixed-income instruments issued by companies. As a result of an illiquid secondary market and a lack-lustre primary market, investment in these instruments is largely skewed towards issues from financial institutions. 

While you might find some high-yielding options in the secondary market, if you do not want the problems associated with bad deliveries and the transfer process or you want to invest a large sum of money, the primary market is the better option.


5. Mutual Funds
Unless you rate high on our Investment IQ Test, use mutual funds as a vehicle to invest 

Have you ever made an investment in partnership with someone else? Well, mutual funds work on more or less the same principles. Investors pool together their money to buy stocks, bonds, or any other investments. 

Investing through mutual funds allows an investor to - 

1. Avail the services of a professional money manager (who manages the mutual fund)
2. Access a diversified portfolio despite making a limited investment 

Our primer Investing in Mutual Funds should educate you a lot more on the benefits of investing in mutual funds and strategies you could employ. 


6. Life Insurance Policies
Don't buy life insurance solely as an investment 

Life insurance premiums, depending upon the policy selected, include the costs of - 

1) death-benefit coverage 

2) built-in investment returns (average 8.0% to 9.5% post-tax)

3) significant overheads, including commissions. 

This implies that if you buy insurance solely as an investment, you are incurring costs that you would not incur in alternate investment options. 

It is, however, important to insure your life if your financial needs and profile so require. Use our Are You Adequately Insured planning tool to find out if you need life insurance, and if yes, how much. 


7. Equity Shares
Maximum returns over the long-term, invest funds you do not need for at least five years 

There are two ways in which you can invest in equities- 

1. through the secondary market (by buying shares that are listed on the stock exchanges) 
2. through the primary market (by applying for shares that are offered to the public) 

Over the long term, equity shares have offered the maximum return to investors. As an investment option, investing in equity shares is also perceived to carry a high level of risk. 

Learn more about building an equity portfolio in Investing in Equities 

Know About Cancer Insurance Plans and Why You Need It?

Cancer is one of the most dangerous diseases and everyone knows that it is a lethal disease that requires a lot of money for the proper m...